What Five-Star Airbnb Reviews Have in Common

Ask most hosts what earns a five-star review and they'll talk about the property: the décor, the location, the hot tub. When we read back through our own guest reviews, the big stuff hardly comes up. What guests mention, again and again, is how the stay felt.

Here are the five things that keep turning up, and what we do about each one.

Five-star guest review for a short-let managed by AJM Letting

Five-star guest review for a short-let managed by AJM Letting

1. Fast, friendly replies

This comes up more than anything else. Hannah, who stayed in Braintree, said we were very responsive and the whole stay felt seamless. James, at The Coach House in Congleton, said every question was answered quickly. Another Braintree guest found us so easy to talk to that he extended his stay by five days. And Pat told us our communication had restored their faith in letting agents after a bad experience somewhere else.

None of those reviews mention anything complicated. They mention not being left waiting.

What we do: reply quickly during the day, keep saved replies for the questions every guest asks, and make sure someone is covering evenings and weekends.

2. Spotless, every single time

Clean is the word that turns up in review after review: spotless in Leeds, very clean in Braintree, lovely and clean at the Coach House. Guests notice cleanliness straight away, and it's the one thing a great location can't make up for.

What we do: work to the same checklist at every changeover, check the cleaning before the next guest arrives, and keep fresh linen and spares in stock so nothing gets skipped.

3. A check-in that works first time

Holly Jo, who stayed at our Leeds flat, picked out how clear the entry instructions were. That might sound small, but a guest standing outside in the rain trying to work out a key safe is how a five-star stay becomes a four.

What we do: send check-in details ahead of arrival with photos, test codes before every stay, and always have a backup way in. In line with Airbnb's new house rules, getting in never depends on the guest signing up to an app.

4. A listing that tells the truth

Mahir described our Leeds flat as clean, comfortable and exactly as advertised. Scott, in Congleton for work, said the Coach House was exactly as described. Reviews are really a measure of expectations against reality. If your photos are five years old or your listing oversells, even a good stay can disappoint.

What we do: keep photos current, describe the property honestly, and mention the things that matter to the guest, like parking, noise or stairs, before they book.

5. Small touches

Jordan said the Coach House gave them the best night's sleep ever, and even mentioned the ice already in the freezer. Pat liked the stocked kitchen and our tip for the local fish and chip shop. Derek loved having the Biddulph Valley Way walking route on the doorstep.

None of these cost much. They show someone has thought about the stay from the guest's side.

One thing not to do

Don't ask Airbnb guests to leave reviews on other websites. Airbnb doesn't allow it, and its new house rules make that even clearer. Let a good stay do the work, and reply to every review, good or bad, in a calm and professional way.

A quick checklist

  • Can a guest get a reply within minutes during the day, and within the hour in the evening?

  • Is the cleaning checked, not just done?

  • Would a first-time visitor get in without phoning you?

  • Do your photos and description match the property today?

  • Is there at least one small touch a guest might mention?

Want reviews like these for your place?

Fast replies, consistent cleaning and honest listings are what we do every day for the hosts we manage. If you'd like to hand over your short-let, we'll start with a free valuation.

Follow @ajmletting on Instagram for more hosting tips.

Previous
Previous

Your Airbnb Calendar Has Gone Quiet? What to Check First

Next
Next

Will Airbnb Work in My Property? How to Tell